Planning Permission
Planning Permission for Short-Term Lets in Scotland
Planning and licensing are separate requirements. Having a licence does not mean you have planning permission — and you may need both.
Do I Need Planning Permission?
The answer depends on three key factors: where your property is, what type of property it is, and when you started letting.
You almost certainly need planning permission if:
- !Your property is in a Short-Term Let Control Area AND is a secondary let (not your main home)
- !Your property is a residential flat being converted to STL use in Edinburgh
- !You're changing the use of a dwelling to commercial-scale letting
You may not need planning permission if:
- ✓You operate a home-let or home-share (your principal home)
- ✓Your use pre-dates the control area's confirmation (Muirhead [2023] CSOH 86)
- ✓Your property is a house (not a flat) and use falls within Class 9 of the Use Classes Order
- ✓You are converting from commercial/office use to STL (often viewed more favourably)
Having a licence does NOT protect you from planning enforcement. A Planning Enforcement Notice can force you to cease trading in as little as 2 months, even with a valid licence. Licensing and planning are separate legal requirements under separate departments.
Short-Term Let Control Areas (STLCAs)
Under Section 26B of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997:
“In a short-term let control area, the use of a dwellinghouse for the purpose of providing short-term lets is deemed to involve a material change of use of the dwellinghouse.”
This means in a control area, secondary letting automatically triggers a need for planning permission. No assessment of “fact and degree” is needed — the requirement is deemed.
Current Control Areas (only 2 in Scotland)
City of Edinburgh
Whole city. Confirmed 5 September 2022.
4,300+ STL licences issued. 5% visitor levy from July 2026.
Highland — Badenoch & Strathspey
One ward only. Confirmed 4 March 2024.
Highland considering widening the area. Other councils also considering STLCAs.
Key Exceptions
- Home-lets and home-shares are exempt from the automatic planning requirement (the property must be the landlord's principal home)
- Pre-existing uses that began before the STLCA was confirmed do not trigger Section 26B (Muirhead [2023] CSOH 86)
Being exempt from a control area does NOT mean you don't need planning permission. There may be no automatic requirement under Section 26B, but a need may still exist under Section 26(1) of the 1997 Act. A material change of use always requires planning permission, whether or not a control area applies.
Certificate of Lawfulness (CLUD)
A Certificate of Lawful Use or Development (CLUD) confirms that your existing STL use is lawful and does not require planning permission. This is particularly relevant for:
- Properties where STL use pre-dates a control area
- Houses where use may fall within Class 9 of the Use Classes Order
- Established uses that have been continuous and unchallenged
STL Solutions has been successful in obtaining Certificates of Lawfulness on behalf of clients, supported by relevant case law including Pirniefield Grove (CLUD-230-2003) and Restalrig Road (CLUD-230-2006).
No retrospective surcharge applies to Certificate of Lawfulness applications, unlike standard planning permission applications.
Planning Application Fees
Planning fees are based on the gross external floor area of your property — measured from the outside of external walls, not internal “skirting to skirting” measurements. This often adds 10+ square metres and can push you into a higher fee band.
| Gross External Area | Standard Fee | + 25% Retrospective Surcharge |
|---|---|---|
| Under 100 sqm | £691 | £863.75 |
| 100–200 sqm | £1,382 | £1,727.50 |
| 200+ sqm | £2,073+ | £2,591.25+ |
A 15% fee increase applied from 12 December 2024, with a further increase in June 2025.
The “free go” rule: if you reapply within 12 months of a refusal (at the same site, for the same type of application), the fee is waived. This does not apply across different application types (e.g. a previous CLUD does not exempt you from planning permission fees).
Certificate of Lawfulness applications have no retrospective surcharge.
The Use Classes Order Question
The Town and Country Planning (Use Classes) (Scotland) Order 1997 defines Class 9, which covers use of a house “whether or not as a sole or main residence” by a single person, family, or up to 5 residents.
Most local authorities confirm in their guidance that STL use of a house that falls within Class 9 will not require planning permission. Historical DPEA decisions have supported this position — notably Pirniefield Grove (CLUD-230-2003) and Restalrig Road (CLUD-230-2006).
However, recent cases — including ENA-230-2327 and CLUD-230-2044 — have denied lawfulness without mentioning the UCO, creating inconsistency. This remains an evolving area of law where expert advice is essential.
Edinburgh Planning Decisions — Key Patterns
Analysis of Edinburgh Council's 2025 planning decisions reveals a clear pattern:
✓ More likely to be granted
- Office → serviced apartments
- Commercial → STL
- Former restaurant/club → STL
- Storage/garage → STL
✗ More likely to be refused
- Residential flat → STL
- Dwelling house → STL
- Shared-stair flats
- Retrospective residential conversions
The property type and its existing use class matter enormously. STL Solutions can advise on the best approach for your specific property.
Planning Refused? We Have Strategies
With a 90% refusal rate in Edinburgh, many operators assume planning permission is impossible. It isn't — but it requires the right strategy for your specific circumstances. Even where planning permission is unlikely, we have multiple alternative approaches:
Certificate of Lawfulness (CLUD)
If your use is already established and lawful, a CLUD confirms this formally — no planning permission needed. This is often the strongest strategy for pre-existing operators. From £1,199 →
Targeted planning applications
When planning permission IS needed, we frame applications on the strongest possible grounds — targeting the specific development plan policies and material considerations most likely to succeed in your council area.
Enforcement defence
If you're facing enforcement action, we have strategies to extend trading time, challenge notices, and have Enforcement Notices quashed. Enforcement & Appeals →
Use class arguments
For houses (not flats), Class 9 of the Use Classes Order may mean your use doesn't require planning permission at all. We assess whether UCO arguments apply to your property.
Pre-STLCA established use
If you were operating before the control area was confirmed, Muirhead [2023] establishes that Section 26B does not apply. We can argue your use is established.
Appeal & review
A refusal is not the end. Planning appeals to the DPEA, local reviews, and “free go” resubmissions are all viable routes. Discuss with Ross Armstrong →
Planning Appeals
If your planning application is refused, or if you receive a Planning Enforcement Notice, you have the right to appeal. Appeals are handled by the DPEA (Directorate for Planning and Environmental Appeals).
STL Solutions has significant experience framing appropriate legal arguments for planning appeals. We have successfully extended trading time for clients and seen Enforcement Notices quashed entirely.
Appeal deadlines are often short and mandated strictly by law. If you receive an enforcement notice or refusal, seek advice immediately.
Not sure about your planning position?
Planning is complex and the consequences of getting it wrong are severe. Get expert advice before you commit time and money to an application.
Book Free Consultation